1 by 1 pix

One Trick That can 3X Your Yelp Leads in Less than 1 Month (and it’s not what you think)

Nov 25, 2019 | Knowledge

One Trick That can 3X Your Yelp Leads in Less than 1 Month (and it’s not what you think)

When it comes to Yelp, many businesses often experience success, even if they don’t subscribe to a monthly advertising program. If you want to be successful on Yelp, we have a few tips to help you optimize your listing for results.

Many business owners think of Yelp as a “4 Letter Word” never to be muttered in their presence. However, many of our clients see tremendous success with Yelp, even if they don’t subscribe to a monthly advertising plan. Here’s the most significant factor that determines your success on Yelp (along with a couple others you should be using).

The key to a strong Yelp listing is the “Response Time” metric.

There are many important elements to a great Yelp listing and many things you can do to make yours stand out.

These include:

  • Maximizing the # of reviews
  • Keeping your pictures updated and attractive
  • Creating graphics to showcase your reviews
  • And much more.

However, in our experience, the key to truly maximizing your profile’s effectiveness and maximizing leads is to:

  1. Enable messaging
  2. Respond quickly to your inquiries.

Since most people want immediate answers to their questions, a 10 minute response time can skyrocket your lead volume.

When people anticipate a quick response, they’re more likely to engage in conversation!

Nobody likes to sit around and wait for a business to get back to them. It’s painful to engage with a business that gives off the impression that it can’t be bothered to talk to customers. Therefore, a “green” response time on Yelp is super-inviting to potential customers and can be the differentiator between your business and the 15 other similar businesses in your city.

“Wait… how do I enable messaging through Yelp? I wasn’t even aware that was a thing!”

If that’s what you’re thinking, the answer is yes! It’s actually very simple. All you need to do is access your business owner Yelp account via biz.yelp.com, click “Inbox” on the left side of the screen, then the “gear” icon in the top right corner. This will allow you to select an option to “Enable” Yelp messaging.

“How am I supposed to respond to my Yelp messages within 10 minutes? I’m hardly ever by a computer!”

Easy! Just download the Yelp Business app, sign in with your username and password, and voila! You can respond to messages directly from your phone. Or, you can put one of your team members in charge of responding to your messages. However you decide to handle it, a 10 minute response time can be the key differentiator between you and everyone else and can not be ignored.

“What should I say to people in my Yelp message responses?”

Typically the best way to answer a Yelp message is to provide the information your potential customer is requesting but to also offer a phone conversation. This way, you can follow up with the customer and answer all their questions in a single conversation (instead of being tied to a phone messaging conversation).

However, do be aware that many people prefer to message with you because they’re unable to talk on the phone. For instance, many of your potential customers likely contact you while they’re at work or in other situations which do not allow for an immediate phone conversation.

“Now that I have Yelp messaging enabled and a process in place to respond to each message within 10 minutes, how can I get more people to message my business?”

There are a few little-known ways you can get more Yelp engagement.

  • Add video to your profile: This is an element to an “Enhanced Profile” which, at the time of this writing, costs roughly $90. If you’re interested in setting this up, we can handle it for you and you can go ahead and contact us here. Videos are often more engaging than simple photos and, again, serve to differentiate your business from competitors.
  • Create graphics which showcase your best reviews: At the time of this writing, showcasing your reviews with custom graphics placed in the photos is not a violation of Yelp’s policy. That might change, but as of right now, it remains a great way to put your best reviews “front and center.”
  • And of course, always respond to your reviews…. good or bad!

Grab our free guide to learn the top ways to grow your business online this year

Name(Required)
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form

Get Your No-Cost Digital Success Blueprint

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form

Recent Blogs

Best Digital Marketing Platforms for Small Businesses

Small businesses today face no shortage of digital marketing platforms. From search engines to social media to email automation tools, the options can feel overwhelming. The challenge isn’t access, it’s knowing which platforms will actually drive growth instead of...

How to Get Inspiration for AI-Worthy Blog Content

Creating consistent blog content is a challenge many businesses face. Blogging is important for SEO, visibility, and authority, but coming up with fresh, valuable ideas month after month can feel overwhelming. This is where AI can be incredibly helpful, but only when...

How to Get Started With Digital Marketing for Your Business

Digital marketing can feel overwhelming when you’re just getting started. With so many platforms, tools, and “expert” opinions, it’s easy to feel unsure about where to begin. The truth is, successful digital marketing doesn’t start with advanced tactics. It starts...

Why Strategy Matters More Than Tools in Digital Marketing

In today’s digital landscape, it’s easy to get caught up in the latest marketing tools and platforms. From Google Ads and Meta Ads to email automation and AI content tools, businesses are constantly told that success comes from adopting the newest technology. However,...

The Role of SEO in a Successful Digital Marketing Strategy

Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is one of the most powerful and long-lasting assets a business can build in digital marketing. While paid advertising and social media campaigns can drive short-term traffic, SEO creates sustainable visibility that continues to...

How to Make the Most of Your Marketing in 2026

Maximizing Your Marketing in 2026: Strategies to Stay Ahead As we step into 2026, the digital marketing landscape continues to quickly evolve. Businesses that want to stay ahead need more than just a presence online. They need a strategy that’s smart, adaptive, and...

PPC or SEO — Which is best?

PPC or SEO? How to Decide Where to Invest Your Marketing Budget One of the most common questions business owners ask is, “Should I be investing in PPC Google Ads or SEO?” And while it would be convenient to pick just one, the honest answer is more nuanced. Your best...

How to Use Youtube to Boost SEO

How to Use YouTube to Boost Your SEO (and Why It Works) When most people think of SEO, they think of Google Search. But one of the most overlooked platforms for improving your visibility, both on Google and across the web, is YouTube. With over 2 billion monthly users...

Categories